Instructions
- 01
Poke the Pockets
Lightly poke small pockets into each side of the meat with a knife. This is the whole trick: the seasoning gets downinto the meat, not just on the surface. I don’t think most people do this.
- 02
Binder & First Layer — Massage It In
Coat both shoulders with olive oil. Dust a light first layer of each of the four rubs over everything and massage it in by hand, working it down into the pockets.
- 03
Heavy Overcoat — Pat, Don’t Rub
Second pass: a heavy coat of the rubs over everything,patted down onto the surface. Pat, don’t rub — the overcoat stays where you put it.
- 04
Rack It & Let the Fridge Work
Onto a wire rack over a sheet pan and into the fridge to set. These went in Friday for aSunday smoke. By Friday night the rub had hydrated and the surface was sweating — that’s the salt doing its work. By Saturday night the crust had tacked up deep mahogany.
- 05
250°F, Lid Closed, Hands Off
Smoker on at 8:22 AM on a 42°F morning; meat on at9:00 AM with a probe in each shoulder. Settle the pit at 250°F and keep the lid closed and untouched until the internal hits150°F. The dual-wall ceramic holds temp steady even when it’s cold out.
- 06
Baste at 150°F, Baste Again at 175°F
At 150°F (11:48 AM on this cook), baste with melted garlic herb butter. At 175°F(1:03 PM), baste again. No wrapping yet — the bastes are what build that dark, glossy bark.
- 07
Wrap with Wagyu Tallow — and Kill the Heat
At 202°F and probe tender, pull the shoulders and wrap them in butcher paperwith wagyu beef tallow (this cook came off at2:45 PM). While you wrap, shut the smoker off and leave the lidopen to shed heat — the ceramic holds heat so well you have to let some go, or the rest turns into more cooking.
- 08
Rest in the Cooling Ceramic, Then Pull
The wrapped shoulders go back into the cooling smoker and rest there until serving — about3¼ hours on this cook — keeping the internal at or above 145°F. Pull, mix the bark chunks through, and serve. These were on the table by about 6 PM. Verdict: “This was bomb!”









